The Ministry for the Future

audio cd, 1 páginas

Publicado el 6 de octubre de 2020 por Hachette B and Blackstone Publishing, Orbit.

ISBN:
978-1-5491-6178-0
¡ISBN copiado!

Ver en OpenLibrary

It's a Kim Stanley Robinson novel 🙄

By which I mean it's long and has an interesting idea for a plot, but is written in a way that isn't always interesting.

There's something didactic about KSR's novels. He does a lot of telling rather than showing. There are pages and pages of this. Some of it was so tedious that in the last 20% of the book I skipped over parts. I longed for it all to be over so that I could move on to something more interesting and better written.

There are chapters narrated from the point of view of unidentified people who are scientists, refugees, etc. A lot of these all sound like the same rather breathless, over-excited person.

Because of these faults I wouldn't particularly recommend this book.

Une anticipation inégale comme bonne introduction

J'ai lu la version originale en anglais.

Je suis partagé sur le livre :

la mise en scène initiale bouscule et fait réfléchir, l'anticipation s'avère clairvoyante. le livre est bien documenté à de très nombreux titres, malheureusement il y a tellement de sujet à traiter que certains développements (technologiques) s'avèrent inexactes ou au mieux de la fantaisies l'auteur bascule entre description voire essai (documentée) et perspective de personnage. Sur la deuxieme partie ce style s'alourdit et rend la lecture difficile. la discussion des perspectives morales au travers des personnages s'avèrent être la partie la plus intéressante, selon moi. j'ai trouvé le développement heureux final déconnecté avec les travaux récents du GIEC, en particulier la perspective de sobriété n'est pas assez développée j'ai également trouvé certaines résolutions trop candides, j'avoue rester fort cynique quand à l'altruisme des puissants. Cela étant, je trouve cette fiction une bonne introduction au sujet …

Hieno visio siitä, miten ihmiskunta selätti ilmastonmuutoksen

Todella monen asian pitää muuttua, jos aiomme elää tällä planeetalla vielä tulevinakin vuosisatoina. Valtaosa kirjojen ja elokuvien tulevaisuusvisioista tuntuu kuitenkin olevan dystopioita, kuvauksia siitä millaista helvettiä elämä Maa-planeetalla on, kun kaikki on mennyt pieleen. Muutamalla seuraaville vuosikymmenille lähitulevaisuuteen sijoittuva Kim Stanley Robinsonin The Ministry for the Future kuitenkin esittää uskottavan, vaikkakin monelta osin silmiinpistävän optimistisen vision siitä, miten kaikenkattava ekokriisi on saatu Maa-planeetalla kuitenkin jonkinlaiseen hallintaan. Robinsonin visiosta kiinnostavan tekee se, että se ei ole vain kaunokirjallista kuvitelmaa, vaan perustuu ihan todellisiin haasteisiin ja ratkaisuihin, ja monet kirjan luvuista ovatkin luonteeltaan pikemminkin tieteellisiä esseitä kuin varsinaista kertomakirjallisuutta.

Kirjan tulevaisuuskuva ei kuitenkaan ole paratiisimainen utopia. Maa siinä vaiheessa, kun ilmakehän hiilidioksidimäärä on saatu laskuun, ei ole enää aivan sama planeetta kuin se oli vielä ennen ilmastokriisiä, ja työn planeetan hengissäpitämiseksi kuvataan jatkuvan vielä tulevillekin vuosisadoille vaikka hiilidioksidiongelma kirjassa on saatukin pois päällimmäisistä huolenaiheista.

Robinson ei pyri hahmottelemaan paluuta meneen …

Gets a lot right, but with some painful blind spots

Advertencia de contenido Spoilers for the whole book; references to disturbing content

Somehow both harrowingly realistic and implausibly optimistic

The Ministry for the Future follows the history of the eponymous ministry created by the UN in 2025 to represent the interests of future people when addressing #ClimateChange; given that the solutions to climate change will take effect over hundreds of years, so don't immediately benefit the current generations, the ministry would speak for future generations in order to ensure long-term thinking is applied.

The novel has three main characters: Frank, who we meet in the first traumatising chapter, is an American relief worker, and the only survivor of an Indian town struck by a devastating heatwave that wipes out millions. Frank suffers the rest of his ruined life with acute PTSD, which drives him ever more desperately find ways to avoid such a catastrophe from repeating. Early in the novel, it spurs him to actions that introducing us to the second main character:

Mary, an Irish lifetime …

Repackaged state power as a solution to the climate crisis.

What would a worldwide, lasting revolution look like? What would be the obstacles and what tactics would be needed to overcome them? How are we going to survive climate change? These are the themes Kim Stanley Robinson tackles in his 570-page cli-fi novel THE MINISTRY FOR THE FUTURE.

The narrative is disjointed, with epistolary chapters placed throughout. If you roll with it, it works well. You get a well-researched, fairly well-rounded picture across class, power, and geography. The format makes for a clever way to introduce details that otherwise might not fit into a traditional narrative. I also appreciate the global perspective of this book. The U.S. is not at the center at all, and is critiqued heavily and fairly.

THE MINISTRY FOR THE FUTURE envisions a world that includes the Half-Earth concept as one of its solutions to combat climate change. Half of the planet would be …

KSR trying to answer "how to write about/actually respond to climate change"

So his answers for both, basically: maximalism. The point he's sort of making is that making the planet safely inhabitable is going to take every tactic and every ideology not necessarily working together but working on some piece of the thing. No one actor gets to be the hero (though I do enjoy that KSR's favorite kind of protagonist remains the middle-aged competent lady technocrat–guy's got a type) and while he's sort of indicating that capitalism as we know it has to die, he's not saying that happens through inevitable worker uprising. Some of it's coercion of central banks and some of it's straight-up guerrilla terrorism. Geoengineering happens at varying scales for better and for worse. Massive economic collapses occur. Millions die. And the point I think from KSR is that's the outcome in his most optimistic take. In general with KSR I don't know if I ever fully agree, …

avatar for nigini@velhaestante.com.br

lo valoró con